PDA

View Full Version : ASMFC denies striped bass harvest increase



BILL H
11-09-2010, 11:53 AM
Conservationists praise ASMFC decision on striped bass
Managers reject proposal to increase commercial harvest


CHARLESTON, SC – After months of intense debate, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) announced today that it has denied a proposal to increase the commercial harvest of striped bass by up to 50 percent. Public sentiment has run intensely against the proposal from the moment it was introduced last February, as recreational anglers up and down the East Coast flooded their ASMFC representatives with calls to deny the proposal.

“This is a great day for conservation,” said Richen Brame, CCA Atlantic States Fisheries director. “Managers were very much in danger of increasing mortality at a time when the stock is declining, but they took the conservative approach in light of all the uncertainty surrounding the stock today. They should be commended for refusing to take a path that could have ended in disaster.”

Last February, conservationists were stunned when the ASMFC Striped Bass Management Board chose to ignore a host of significant concerns from scientists and enforcement officers about the health of the striped bass population, and instead directed its staff to draft a proposal to increase commercial harvest. Anglers who remembered the dark years of the ‘70s were alarmed that managers were attempting to ramp up commercial harvest even as anglers were seeing serious warning signs on the water.

“CCA members, particularly in Maine and New Hampshire, have said repeatedly they are not seeing striped bass in the abundance seen just a few years ago,” said Mac McKeever, president of CCA Maine. “Anglers in the northern reaches of the striped bass range are the canaries in the coal mine when it comes to the health of the striped bass population, and anglers here are not encountering anywhere near as many fish as they did just a few years ago. There is definitely reason to be concerned.”

Other warning signs pointing to a need for managers to take a cautious approach include declining trends in the striped bass Juvenile Abundance Index, “significant and unreported” poaching in the Exclusive Economic Zone, and the potentially devastating impact of Mycobacteriosis in Chesapeake Bay, the primary striped bass spawning ground for the entire Atlantic Coast. Seventy percent of the fish sampled there had lesions associated with the disease and in aquaculture, Mycobacteriosis infections are virtually always fatal.
“Our members were especially motivated to contact their representatives on the ASMFC throughout this process and let them know this is no time to be talking about increasing harvest of striped bass,” said Charles A. Witek, chairman of CCA Atlantic Fisheries Committee. “The problems facing striped bass today are far more complex than simple overfishing. Managers did the right thing by taking a precautionary approach to management. Striped bass are the crown jewel of ASMFC’s management successes and should be treated as such.”

shooter
11-09-2010, 12:10 PM
Finally a small step in the right direction!

Scott McGuire
11-09-2010, 12:52 PM
Jim are you sure those weren't mullet?

BILL H
11-09-2010, 01:59 PM
What would you catch with that bait?!! I'd have to hire someone to put it on the hook.

gwag
11-09-2010, 05:42 PM
Jim was that Pelicans Roost at the shops before the ferry?

goose70
11-10-2010, 02:33 PM
The ASMFC announcement sounds like someone saying to me, "I was considering shooting you, but I've decided that I'll just continue to stab you some more." Good news is relative, I guess.

Southern Grin
11-16-2010, 11:24 AM
A good start would be to eliminate the "catch and release" in the Susquehanna flats while fish are spawning in late Feb early March and also do away with the "Spring trophy" season in April. Open Striped Bass season after May 20 of every year. This would allow ample time for "all" fish to spawn and increase high reproduction capabilities.

Alley Cat
11-16-2010, 02:44 PM
A good start would be to eliminate the "catch and release" in the Susquehanna flats while fish are spawning in late Feb early March and also do away with the "Spring trophy" season in April. Open Striped Bass season after May 20 of every year. This would allow ample time for "all" fish to spawn and increase high reproduction capabilities. You got my vote!

BILL H
11-17-2010, 02:44 PM
Do any of you have any proof that the Flats season causes any significant impact on the spawners? I mean real proof. Not just feelings, suspicions, lame comparisons with hauling pregnant women around by the lips or anecdotal information concerning floaters. I mean some real peer-reviewed scientific data which demonstrate that the Flats fishery reduces spawning success by X%. If you don't, then your suggestions are just as ill-informed as last seasons ridiculous restrictions on C&R.

BILL H
11-18-2010, 02:40 PM
Jim,
It doesn't matter when a female fish is killed. It won't spawn again. So the timing of the kill is mostly irrelevant. And I haven't seen any good data on the non-kill impact of the Flats fishery. I just want to hear comparative impact on the fishery of various seasons. I don't think the data are out there. And until we have that information, it is foolish to experiment with "faith-based" fisheries management.

Southern Grin
11-20-2010, 08:58 AM
I beg to differ, a female fish killed while trying to spawn is absolutley ridiculous.

BILL H
11-21-2010, 03:45 PM
I beg to differ, a female fish killed while trying to spawn is absolutley ridiculous.
They aren't spawning on the Flats. Besides, look at these two scenarios. In April 2010, the catch an killers put a female in the box. It will absolutely not spawn in 2011. In scenario 2, 1 out of 100 female fish caught and released dies in March or April 2011. That fish does not spawn either. Net result is the same.

JAMOBX
11-23-2010, 12:20 PM
You all are argueing with someone who can't tell the difference between a Jumping Mullet and a Striper.... Joe RockFish is quite the Celeberty On the OBX.. Due to his Pelican's Roost Report... "Of Hundreds of Dead Baby Stripers" " Made Me Ill"

The Problem with Fishermen is that they won't Unite, is always Rec verses Comm..

When the real problem lies much much up the chain NOAA, and all the DMF's should get a Clue..

I took this personal Joe, because you messed with my employment, I work for The Roost Bait and Tackle Hatteras NC, When you spout BS on the internet, at least have your facts close..Claiming a business has Illegal Fish, that deals in Fish , means BS for me, I get to get visited by the Fish Cops... Thanks...

I am aganist any group that wants more for them and less for someone else..

There is Plenty to go around...

But if you are divided there will be none for all one day..

Well next time ask before you insert foot..

Attached is a picture of The Hundreds of Dead Baby Stripers Joe saw..

JAM

uno
11-23-2010, 03:05 PM
I apologize for any anguish caused but you also know that I also posted a retraction within a few minutes and you didn't post that as well.

Perhaps you need to do more research before you impact anyone's livelihood with your posts/opinions, you may not mean any harm, but words matter and the retractions may not even be noticed.