I don't use a 3.5" gun, but if I was buying a new one the SBEII is the only way to go IMO. I've shot several 3.5's and plain and simple it's the best handling, shooting, cycling and operating gun I've shot. Over the past few years I've shot freinds guns at the range and in the feild. I've shot the 935 Ulti-mag, Extrema and Browing as well as the x-2. The SBE was by far the best. It just felt great, TO ME. For a pump gun I'd go with the Binelli again.....NOVA.....again it jsut felt great...very comfortable. That being said, all my exp is based on my prefernaces. Betwqeen shooting a few models and some advice from the TF brotherhood I'm sure you'll find the right gun for you.
The SBEII is pricey, no doubt but when I can afford it I'm getting one[grin]