Tidal Fish Forum banner
21 - 37 of 37 Posts
Great, now I'm gonna have to eat one just to satisfy my curiosity. Bryansfish I only stuck a finger in the mouth of a live oyster toad once about twenty years ago and I came away with a blood blister after my father pried it's mouth open with pliers. I don't recommend doing it.
 
I have heard (emphasis on "heard") that on Smith Island (just above Tangier) they have an oyster toad fishing contest each year and then a fish fry using the ones they caught. I found it interesting.

I took one of the guys from work fishing one day some years back (he's from Hong Kong) and we caught some oyster toads. He asked me how they tasted. I told him what I had heard and he kept about 10 of them. Monday morning he said they were hard to clean, but not bad tasting.

I've never tried.

AS for the northern stargazer, I won't try since they have a toxic gland that supplies a venom through one of its spines. I had read in a fishing book that the venom is enough to kill an adult male human being. That would be me and I have never tried to eat one ........ nor will I.
 
question

"As such, I usually just use a pair of heavy scissors and cut open one side of its gills....allowing me to remove my hook."

This sounds like until the angler personally found some food value in the oyster toad that it was OK to kill them all. Not to sound like a tree hugger but why not just cut the hook? Just my opinion...and I know what they say about those.
 
Well, I've tried dogfish...and found it tasty. So I guess I'll keep the next "toad" and give it a try. Doubt I'll get Brian to eat any though!
Before Wanchese harbor got all developed, there was a seafood festival every year. The local NOAA guys would have a booth with dogfish that they fried up, trying to get people use to the idea of eating them. It tasted as good as catfish. I liked it. DP
 
21 - 37 of 37 Posts